During COVID-19 when everybody had a lot more time on their hands, one of the things I took up was using safety razors to shave. And with that, I also had to find the right shaving cream to go with. That was the springboard into soaps in general. On this page, you can find my personal ratings and notes for both shaving and bath soaps over time. These are just my personal opinions, as I’m not a professional soapologist. Your mileage may vary.

NameVendorRatingNotes
Citrus Spectre
Floïd
Floïd★★★★★Very subtle. Super smooth.
Jermyn Street CollectionTaylor of Old Bond Street★★★★★Good lather.
No. 63
Pre de Provence
Pre de Provence★★★★★Really great cedar scent.
Pig TrailStirling Soap Company★★★★★Festive and piney, but really good all year ‘round!
Scottish Thistle & Black Pepper Soap Body BarScottish Fine Soaps Company★★★★★
Sea salt with ocean mineralsAustralian Botanicals★★★★★
Black IceStirling Soap Company★★★★☆It has a strong anise scent when using, but it doesn’t linger after use.
Cool BlueStirling Soap Company★★★★☆
DukeStirling Soap Company★★★★☆
FacialStirling Soap Company★★★★☆Very strong lemon scent. Very refreshing, but probably best used in spring or summer.
Mr. TaylorTaylor of Old Bond Street★★★★☆
RaspberryAustralian Botanicals★★★★☆
Rosemary MintStirling Soap Company★★★★☆
Valencia OrangeAustralian Botanicals★★★★☆
Bay Rum and Sweet OrangeOgallala★★★☆☆Not a fan of the sweet orange scent, but lathers well.
BlackStirling Soap Company★★★☆☆
Chestnuts RoastingStirling Soap Company★★★☆☆
EggnogStirling Soap Company★★★☆☆Unsurprisingly this is best suited for winter.
Eton CollegeTaylor of Old Bond Street★★★☆☆
EucalyptusAustralian Botanicals★★★☆☆
Lavender
Pre de Provence
Pre de Provence★★★☆☆
LemongrassAustralian Botanicals★★★☆☆
PiacenzaStirling Soap Company★★★☆☆
British LeatherStirling Soap Company★★☆☆☆
72% Marseille
Pre de Provence
Pre de Provence★☆☆☆☆Do not like the smell. it smells oily.
Iced CoffeeStirling Soap Company★☆☆☆☆Does not smell like coffee. Overpowering scent.
Sherlock
Chiseled Face
Chiseled Face
NameVendorRatingNotes
Tabac Original
Tabac
Tabac★★★★★
Shaving CreamSpeick★★★★☆Strong lavender scent, but not overwhelming. Has a really good lather to it.